Acoustic VS Electric Drum Kits: A First-Time Buyer's Guide
For aspiring drummers and first-time buyers, choosing the right drum kit can be a daunting task. Among the many decisions to make, one of the most significant is whether to opt for an acoustic drum kit or an electric drum kit. Both options have their merits, but they offer distinct experiences, sounds, and features. In this blog, we'll break down the differences between these two types of drum kits to help you make the best choice for you.
Sound Quality and Volume
One of the most critical distinctions between acoustic and electric drum kits is sound quality and volume.
Acoustic Drum Kits: Acoustic drums are known for their rich, organic sound. They produce sound through physical vibration, creating an authentic and powerful drumming experience. The resonance and natural tone of an acoustic kit make it ideal for live performances, recording sessions, and almost all drumming styles.
However, acoustic drums are inherently loud, which can be both an advantage and a drawback. The volume may be too much for home practice without proper soundproofing, and it can be a concern for neighbours or family members. This is why at BTN Drum Academy, we teach proper Dynamics. This means that we teach our students the art of controlling their volume.
Electric Drum Kits: Electric drum kits utilize electronic sensors to trigger sounds. Depending on the style of kit and the price point, they can be highly adjustable, allowing you to change the kit's sound by selecting different presets or even creating your own custom sounds. Electric kits are generally quieter than acoustic drums, thanks to the option to use headphones or connect to an amplifier. This makes them suitable for quiet practice sessions.
The sound produced by electric drum kits can be less dynamic and organic compared to acoustic drums. While they are excellent for electronic music genres and for drummers who need to practice quietly, however they tend to lack the depth and authenticity of acoustic kits.
Portability and Space
Another factor to consider is portability and space requirements.
Acoustic Drum Kits: Acoustic drum kits can be large and heavy. They require ample space for setup and storage, making them less convenient if you have limited space or need to transport them frequently. Additionally, assembling and tuning an acoustic kit can be seen as time-consuming. Again, we love to teach how to setup and tear down kits at BTN which makes this aspect of owning a drum set a bit easier!
Electric Drum Kits: Electric drum kits are compact and lightweight, making them an excellent choice for drummers with limited space or those who need to transport their kit regularly. They also can be easy to set up and typically come with adjustable rack systems for customization.
Versatility
Acoustic Drum Kits: Acoustic drum kits offer an almost endless range of sonic possibilities through drumhead and cymbal choices, material of drums (wood, metal..) tuning, and different miking techniques. They are versatile for playing various music genres and adapting to different playing styles.
Electric Drum Kits: Electric drum kits are also very versatile as they offer various preset sounds, sound editing options, and the ability to integrate with software and electronic music production. This versatility however is only as profound as the price you’re willing to pay. Newer and more expensive electric kits will offer so much more than an entry level kit can give.
Price and Maintenance
Acoustic Drum Kits: Acoustic drum kits vary in price, especially when considering the need for quality cymbals, hardware, and regular maintenance. Drumheads wear out, and tuning requires skill and time. However, if well-maintained, they can last for many, many years.
Electric Drum Kits: As acoustic kits, Electric drum kits also vary in price, but require very little maintenance. You won't need to purchase replacement drumheads or tune the drums. However, electronic components will always eventually breakdown and need replacement and when they do, parts can sometimes be hard to come by. Make sure you have a killer warranty for this.
In conclusion, the choice between an acoustic and electric drum kit ultimately depends on your specific needs and preferences. First, consider your budget, playing environment, musical goals, and preferred playing style when making your decision. If you’re connected with a drum coach, teacher or family member that knows a thing or two about drums, ask questions. Check Online for used options. Whichever you choose, remember that both acoustic and electric drum kits can be a gateway to a fulfilling and exciting drumming journey.